Yorkshire: Library drops £3,000 fine after book returned 76 years late


Charlie Studdy with the book he returned to Keighley Library almost 76 years late (Pictures: SWNS)

A library has waived fines totalling more than £3,000 after an overdue book was finally returned – 76 years late.

Charlie Studdy came across ‘This Way To The Tomb’ – a play by Ronald Duncan – when tidying up a bookcase at his home in Goole, East Yorkshire, and discovered it was due back on July 17, 1946.

His late mother Eileen Hoyle, who he described as an ‘avid reader’, is believed to have borrowed it when she returned home to Haworth, West Yorkshire, from university.

It had been on the library’s shelves for less than a month and had only been borrowed once prior to being taken out by Eileen.

It is believed the book, ‘This Way To The Tomb’, was borrowed by Charlie’s late mum (Picture: Bradford Council/SWNS)
The book had only been borrowed once before (Picture: Bradford Council/SWNS)
Charlie Studdy (right) outside Keighley Library with Partrick Hill, Library Team Leader of Bradford Council (Picture: Bradford Council/SWNS)

Charlie said forgetting to take it back would have been ‘out of character’ for his mum.

Staff at Kingsley Library and Local Studies in Bradford realised that if they backdated the 15p-a-day overdue return fees, Charlie could have found himself having to pay an eye-watering £3,552.45.

However, they instead agreed to impose a ‘fine amnesty’ – enacted during the pandemic to encourage readers to bring back overdue books – and put the book on display as part of its 150th anniversary celebrations.

Staff realised that if they charged him the current rate of 15p a day, it would cost him £3,552.45 (Picture: Bradford Council / SWNS)

Charlie said of the discovery: ‘It happened quite by chance. I was tidying up some bookshelves at the beginning of this week when I came across it.

‘I didn’t recognise it and so I believe it came from my mother’s house after we cleared it out when she passed away nine years ago.

‘It’s likely that it was borrowed from the library when she returned home from university for the holidays and forgot to take it back.

Charlie discovered the book when tidying up a bookcase (Picture: Bradford Council / SWNS)

‘She wasn’t in a university drama group as far as I know, but she was a very wide and enthusiastic reader, so it’s not surprising she had a copy.

‘My mother loved books all the way through her life. She was an avid reader until the end.’

Eileen studied at London University before being transferred to Cambridge University during World War II.

She was a regional manager for the Citizens Advice Bureau later in her life and was awarded an MBE for services to the organisation.

The book was due back on June 17, 1946 (Picture: Bradford Council / SWNS)

Councillor Sarah Ferriby of Bradford Council said: ‘This is such a lovely story and it’s great to see the book being returned. It is now on display at our Keighley Library.

‘We have operated several “fines amnesties” during the pandemic to encourage readers to bring back their overdue books, however 76 years is somewhat of a record for our libraries.

‘We obviously wouldn’t charge Mr Studdy for his mother’s overdue book, and readers can rest assured we would never charge more than the book is worth, however late it is!

‘We would far rather get the books and the customers back wherever possible.

‘Our Libraries Service is celebrating its 150th anniversary this year so it’s remarkable that this book has been on loan for over half of that time.’

Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at [email protected].

For more stories like this, check our news page.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here